NOSTALGIA: Costco Backlash Erupts

Exterior view of a Costco Wholesale store with a clear blue sky
Photo: Jonathan Weiss / Shutterstock

Costco shoppers still talk about a $4.99 sandwich that vanished from food courts years ago, and they want it back.

Quick Take

  • Costco shoppers are publicly reminiscing about the chain’s discontinued $4.99 brisket sandwich.
  • Reports say Costco began pulling it from some food courts in 2018, and it was gone from all locations by around 2020.
  • The push mirrors an earlier, much larger campaign to bring back Costco’s food court combo pizza, which Costco has not revived.
  • Costco has not issued a public statement explaining why the sandwich disappeared or whether it might return.

Shoppers Remember The $4.99 Brisket Sandwich

Costco customers are speaking up about a food court item they say they miss: the $4.99 brisket sandwich. Fox News reported shoppers calling for its comeback, years after it quietly left menus nationwide. The sandwich carried a fixed, memorable price tag, the kind of deal Costco built its reputation on. That price point is part of why people still bring it up today.

The disappearance did not happen all at once. Reporting shows Costco started removing the brisket sandwich from some food courts back in 2018. By roughly 2020, it had vanished from the menu entirely. That slow fade means some shoppers noticed the loss years before others, which helps explain why memories of exactly when it left differ from store to store.

A Familiar Pattern At Costco’s Food Court

This is not the first time Costco shoppers have mourned a lost menu item. The food court’s combo pizza, discontinued in 2020, sparked a petition that passed 18,700 signatures by September 2024. Despite that visible support, Costco has maintained it will not bring back the ready-to-eat version of the pizza. That history matters here. It shows loud public nostalgia does not automatically translate into a menu reversal.

Costco’s food court plays a bigger role in the company’s business than its low prices suggest. Industry analysts have noted the food court is a high-margin side operation that keeps members walking through the door and renewing their cards. Menu decisions there are not made on sentiment alone. They involve ingredient costs, prep time, and how an item fits the broader lineup, factors the public rarely sees.

Why Nostalgia Alone Rarely Reverses A Menu Decision

Food brands across the industry have learned that nostalgia sells. Restaurant analysts point out that classic, discontinued items connect strongly with both older customers reliving memories and younger diners discovering them for the first time. One industry analyst noted that nostalgia resonates with millennials and Gen Z shoppers alike, even those too young to have tried the original item themselves.

That dynamic has pushed some chains to bring items back. Taco Bell once polled customers directly on which discontinued item they wanted most, picking a winner between two former menu staples. Other brands have revived items shelved for decades once demand proved durable rather than fleeting. Costco has not signaled it plans a similar poll or revival for the brisket sandwich, but the industry playbook shows such requests are taken seriously elsewhere.

For now, the brisket sandwich remains a memory rather than a menu item. Shoppers keep bringing it up in conversations and online, much like they did with the combo pizza before that campaign stalled. Costco has not addressed the calls publicly, leaving the company’s reasoning, and any chance of a comeback, unanswered. Until Costco says otherwise, the $4.99 sandwich stays a food court legend rather than a current option.

What happens next likely depends on whether this stays a scattered wave of nostalgia or grows into an organized push, like the pizza petition before it. Costco has shown it can absorb that kind of pressure without changing course. Shoppers hoping for the sandwich’s return may be waiting a while, unless the company decides the demand is worth the cost of bringing it back.

Sources:

foxnews.com, foodrepublic.com, noticias.foxnews.com, tastingtable.com, chowhound.com