O.J. Case Takes a Turn

O. J. Simpson and Paula Barbieri posing together at an event
Photo: Shutterstock

Nine fingerprints pulled from the Bundy Drive crime scene in the O.J. Simpson murder case were never matched to anyone, and more than 30 years later, the Los Angeles Police Department still calls the file open.

Quick Take

  • A defense fingerprint expert testified in 1995 that nine prints found at the crime scene could not be matched to any known person.
  • Searches in 1994 relied on local and regional fingerprint systems, which may have missed records from states like New York or Florida.
  • A new documentary argues modern databases and analysis tools could offer a fresh shot at identifying the prints.
  • The Los Angeles Police Department says the Simpson case remains open, though it has not confirmed any new testing.

The Trial Testimony That Revealed Nine Unmatched Prints

During the 1995 murder trial, defense fingerprint specialist Gilbert Aguilar told jurors that nine fingerprints lifted from the Bundy Drive condominium never matched known samples. Lead defense attorney Johnnie Cochran Jr. questioned him about the discovery. The testimony came during a trial built around disputing the prosecution’s physical evidence, and it has resurfaced now as filmmakers revisit the case three decades later.

Aguilar’s statement was never really a mystery to trial watchers. It simply never led anywhere. No suspect emerged to claim the prints, and the case ended with Simpson’s acquittal on criminal charges in 1995. The unmatched prints sat in the record, mentioned but unresolved, until documentary producers started asking fresh questions about what today’s forensic tools might find.

Why 1994 Technology Left Gaps In The Search

Aguilar explained that the original comparisons ran through local and regional fingerprint systems available at the time. That meant records of people arrested in other states, such as New York or Florida, may never have entered the search at all. A print from an out-of-state visitor could have gone unmatched simply because the system checking it never saw the right records.

Filmmaker Ari Mark, who worked on the new documentary revisiting the case, told reporters that latent print analysis has changed dramatically since 1994. “You can take latent prints and analyze those in a way that you couldn’t before,” Mark said. His point rests on a real shift in the field: fingerprint databases today pull from far wider pools of records than anything available three decades ago.

Los Angeles Police Say The Case Is Still Open

A Los Angeles Police Department spokesperson confirmed to Fox News Digital that “the O.J. Simpson case remains an open and ongoing investigation.” The department said detectives would follow up on any new investigative leads that surface. That statement keeps the door open, but it stopped short of saying whether anyone has actually resubmitted the nine prints to modern systems.

The Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office reportedly received a request from documentary producers asking that the fingerprints be reexamined. No public response from that office has been reported. That gap leaves the public without a clear answer on whether prosecutors have evaluated the request or whether the prints remain in condition suitable for retesting at all.

What Modern Fingerprint Science Can And Cannot Promise

Latent print work has genuinely improved since the mid-1990s, and automated systems can now search records far beyond a single city or county. But fingerprint science is not a magic wand. Research on latent print comparisons shows outcomes depend heavily on print quality and clarity, meaning a smudged or partial print can still defeat even the newest database.

That reality matters here. Nothing in the public record confirms the condition of these nine specific prints, whether they were ever preserved for future testing, or whether a modern search would even generate a workable comparison. The renewed interest reflects a documentary pitch and a department’s acknowledgment that the file stays open, not a confirmed new forensic result.

A Case That Still Pulls At The Public Decades Later

The Simpson case never fully left the national conversation, and theories about a possible second person at the scene have circulated for years. A new docuseries revives that question by tying it to these unmatched prints, giving old speculation a modern forensic hook. Whether that hook leads to an actual name remains to be seen, but the department’s open-file status keeps the possibility alive.

For now, the facts are straightforward. Nine prints went unmatched in 1994. A defense expert said so under oath. A filmmaker is pushing for a second look, and police say the case technically remains open. Nothing more has been confirmed, and that restraint from investigators, rather than hype from a documentary trailer, is the most reliable marker of where this story actually stands.

Sources:

foxnews.com, breakingnewsnation.com, nist.gov, link.springer.com, nij.ojp.gov